• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

Berlin Airlift Thesis Statement

Essay (back to top)

Andrei Cherny’s book, The Candy Bombers: The Untold Story of the Berlin Airlift and America’s Finest Hour, is one of the most recent and thorough contemporary sources on the Berlin Airlift. Using historical data, German and American military correspondence, media coverage, firsthand accounts, and many books from experts in the field, Cherny sets out to unravel the political and social intricacies surrounding the Berlin Blockade, its reception on the home front, and the importance of what would become known as “Operation Little Vittles” in molding German popular opinion. On an international scale, the Berlin Airlift ushered in a new era of political warfare. As World War II came to a close, the world, especially the victors who were to decide Germany’s future, lay war-wearied, their nations bogged down by economic hardship. Where World War II gladly waved goodbye to the atrocities of personal warfare, aerial assaults, and the toppling of the infamous Third Reich, the political tensions heightened as Allied forces, differing in ideologies, clashed over Germany’s capital, Berlin, which became a focal point of the Cold War. Although Cherny argues the Berlin Airlift made the situation in Berlin immeasurably worse and did not assist in alleviating the hunger, pestilence, and misery experienced by its approximately two million inhabitants, I argue that we should not ignore the importance of the Airlift’s “Little Vittles” mission and the positive psychological ramifications it produced. During a time where Berliners had been hungry and cold for almost three years prior to Allied occupation, the Airlift was meant not only to fly in provisions to Berlin, but also to be an inspiration to its peoples’ struggle. The Airlift would change the culture of Berlin and the attitude toward an Allied power that now dropped supplies and candy instead of bombs. A surge in morale and a positive outlook toward American democracy were encouraged by the kindliness of American pilots.

In contrast to Cherny’s argument that the Airlift was a flop, the transportation of provisions into Germany was quite successful. As evidence from the book shows, the Airlift conducted approximately 277,000 flights and 4.6 billion pounds of food and supplies (Cherny, 2008: 543). Out of all airlift efforts, none had been anywhere near as large. Not only were Berliners fed, but through the kindness of strangers and the unwavering efficiency of the Airlift during the winter of 1949, the threat of Soviet confrontation was temporarily negated. Furthermore, the outlook of the German people, who once saw democracy as a moniker, laid new hope in their American saviors and cast off the temptation of communism.

Prior to the Allied occupation of Berlin, the capital had received quite a beating. After nearly four hundred aerial bombing raids by the Americans and the British, Berlin lay pockmarked, collapsed, and its once flourishing infrastructure all but demolished under the sordid mountains of debris (Cherny, 2008: 77-78). With its apartments, government offices, private industry and factories lying in crumbled heaps along the streets of Berlin, the lack of these modern edifices, along with food crops and other means of economic stability destroyed, its inhabitants fell into poverty, its crime rose dramatically, and the severe shortage of food became an increasingly pervasive subject of conversation both in Germany and abroad. It had been decided upon the partitioning among the Allied forces that each power would feed those in its zone of occupation and in its sector of Berlin. Because Berlin lay in the heart of the Soviet zone, the Western allies transported all food and supplies into the city over long distance (Cherny, 2008: 126-128). Each day tens of millions of pounds of foodstuffs, shoes, clothes, newsprint, and coal barely supplied the population of over two million people (Cherny, 2008: 127). Even with rationing of foodstuffs to Berliners, the death rate in late 1947 was three times as high as the birth rate (Cherny, 2008: 127). With their fate temporarily on hold, Berliners found themselves at the hands of an occupier who had wrought havoc on their city, defeated them in battle, and was now the sole way to rebuild.

With the partitioning of Germany into provisional zones, a buildup of tensions between East and West began to take hold of Europe. With the Soviet Union controlling the largest region of eastern Europe and the relative mobility of its army, Moscow began to clash with the policies and democratic institutions the West was attempting to assert in Berlin. With Berlin lying in the center of the Soviet zone, the four Allies would inevitably have to rub against each other, ideologies and all. Berlin would now become the platform for an East versus West showdown. The tension between the United States and the Soviet Union, who had been allies during WWII, now faced off as bitter enemies. Cherny best sums up the conflict when he writes:

A new global conflict between two very different ideologies had arisen, and now was focused on Germany’s capital, a once-great city, toppled by its own evil and hubris, where the Soviets and the Americans had trapped themselves together like scorpions in a bottle. Now the decisive hour had finally come. (Cherny, 2008: 241)

In June 1948, the Soviets, in a decision to take Berlin entirely, halted all travel in and out of the western sectors of Berlin. The Berlin Blockade forced the United States and its Western allies to formulate a plan of action to aid Berliners, stem the threat of socialist overtake, and more importantly, raised the question on how to avoid the possibility of nuclear war.

According to Cherny’s sources, before the blockade Berlin had been bringing in 31 million pounds of supplies a day. Even with the support of the American and British planes, only an estimated half a million pounds could be delivered each day (Cherny, 2008: 252). Indeed, the Airlift could not bring in nearly enough supplies. Cherny asserts that in the early reactions to the Berlin Blockade, the so-called Berlin Airlift never really began. He argues that instead, it was a “ragtag transportation” of insufficient materials in planes ill-equipped to take to the air flown by pilots hardly qualified to fly (Cherny, 2008: 262).

Although one could look to several airlifts in the history of Europe as comparisons to the Berlin Airlift, it is fair to argue the Berlin Airlift was, in fact, successful. With the only other recorded success of an airlift being the American airlift to China during World War II, few other attempts even came close (Cherny, 2008: 323-341). Where the American airlift to China only sought to supply 60,000 military servicemen in need of food and ammunition, the Berlin Airlift supplied two million civilians with food, clothing, fuel, and numerous different consumer goods (Cherney, 2008: 323). However, the two were different undertakings altogether. As previous airlift attempts failed, the Berlin Airlift not only supplied the minimum level of tonnage for daily survival in Berlin, but also symbolically transformed attitudes partially through the distribution of chocolate parachuted from planes landing in Tempelhof airport.

The book suggests the Airlift was not necessarily a direct solution, but was successful in buying time for peace talks between the United States and the Soviet Union as well as molding new viewpoints towards American democracy. Where past airlifts had been merely to sustain a given population, the Berlin Airlift’s purpose was twofold. It did supply Berliners with sufficient provisions, but was also a political power play. As the Cold War became a competition for allegiance, the need to rekindle the element of human compassion for Germany was critical. The distrust between occupiers and occupied was mutual: Germans were weary of their enemies-turned-saviors, and likewise, Allied servicemen had seen Germany as the central figure in two world wars.

The turning point in German attitude came as a result of a highly regimented flight pattern of planes in and out of West Berlin’s airport in addition to the mere human kindness shown in the distribution of hundreds of thousands of pounds of candy to Berlin’s children. The psychic boost of parachuting candy over Berlin drew attention toward the planes landing in the pockmarked runway of Tempelhof airport and the magical candy surprises that rained on rooftops, front lawns, and in the rubble of Berlin’s streets (Cherny, 2008: 343). As 1948 came to a close and with no end to the Blockade in sight, the American Air Force perfected the mechanics of its Airlift program and in addition, had officially adopted the dropping of candy parachutes to Berlin’s children, an operation that became known as “Little Vittles.” As an excerpt from Cherny’s book reflects:

These children had been Hitler’s last hope, inculcated since birth with a hatred for Americans and their wickedly egalitarian democracy. When the war had ended, they had been so scarred by the American aerial attacks that the sight of a lit match sent them into convulsions of terror. An American in uniform--even a Salvation Army uniform--caused them to burst into tears. They had been the children who played the game of “rape.” Now social workers observed that a new game was dominant amid the craters and rubble-strewn streets of Berlin. The city’s children were playing the game of “Airlift.” (Cherny, 2008: 358)

It is hard to ignore the dramatic results the Berlin Airlift produced. As Berlin suffered through one of its harshest winters, the feeling of crisis passed (Cherny, 2008: 508-510). With the Airlift surviving the winter and morale relatively high, the Soviet threat of war fell away. The Soviet technique of instilling fear no longer had validity. Stalin’s strategy to choke out the Western forces had backfired. As the book suggests, many western European nations once threatened by impending Soviet expansion banded together and were seeking defense treaties with the United States (Cherny, 2008: 510). The Airlift had provided evidence that the United States was rejecting its previous isolationist approach to foreign policy and was making headway not only as a strong world leader, but as a humane one as well. The blockade was lifted in May of 1949 and the Airlift ended shortly after. The skies emptied of cargo planes over a newly united democratic West German state.

The Candy Bombers is a plucky historical narrative full of definitive and groundbreaking insight. Although he argues that the Airlift was successful in warranting a positive political response in Berlin, his assertion that the material productivity of the Airlift was the source for a change of heart in Berlin and not, in the least, a direct result of American pilots’ generosity, is unwarranted. I argue that it was the convergence of these two that generated positive German feedback toward democracy and not, in Cherny’s opinion, one rather than the other. Cherny addresses a wide array of audiences. Regardless of previous background in the subject, his book is geared to read clearly and easily for any level of curious historian. Although he is an editor of the idea journal Democracy and a former speechwriter for the White House, he has also authored one other book and several small columns on history, culture, and politics. Cherny may not necessarily be a bona fide historian, but his historical and political insights contribute to the world of academia.

Also on this day

Lead Story

1954

USS Nautilus commissioned

The USS Nautilus, the world’s first nuclear submarine, is commissioned by the U.S. Navy. The Nautilus was constructed under the direction of U.S. Navy Captain Hyman G. Rickover, a brilliant Russian-born engineer who joined the U.S. atomic program in 1946. In 1947, he was put in charge of the navy’s nuclear-propulsion...

American Revolution

1776

Washington blames militia for problems

In a letter to his nephew, Lund Washington, plantation manager of Mount Vernon, General George Washington writes on this day in 1776 of his displeasure with the undisciplined conduct and poor battlefield performance of the American militia. Washington blamed the Patriot reliance on the militia as the chief root of...

Automotive

1955

James Dean dies in car accident

At 5:45 PM on this day in 1955, 24-year-old actor James Dean is killed in Cholame, California, when the Porsche he is driving hits a Ford Tudor sedan at an intersection. The driver of the other car, 23-year-old California Polytechnic State University student Donald Turnupseed, was dazed but mostly uninjured;...

Civil War

1864

Battle of Poplar Springs Church (Peeble’s Farm)

In an attempt to cut the last rail line into Petersburg, Virginia, Union troops attack the Confederate defense around the besieged city on this day in 1864. Although initially successful, the attack ground to a halt when Confederate reinforcements were rushed into place from other sections of the Petersburg line. The...

Crime

1994

A Texas college student kills his ex-girlfriend

Shamburger was then discovered by Baker’s roommate, whom he tied up. Asked if she could identify him, the roommate lied and said no, so Shamburger put her in the trunk of his car. He then drove a few blocks away and returned to the scene to remove the bullet from...

Disaster

1999

Radiation released at Japanese plant

Large doses of radiation are released at Japan’s Tokaimura nuclear plant on this day in 1999. It was Japan’s worst nuclear accident, caused by a serious error made by workers at the plant. One person was killed, 49 were injured and thousands of others were forcibly confined to their homes...

General Interest

1399

Henry IV proclaimed

Henry Bolingbroke is proclaimed King Henry IV of England upon the abdication of King Richard II.Henry was the eldest surviving son of John of Gaunt, duke of Lancaster. While his father was away in Spain, Henry joined other lords in opposing King Richard II’s rule. Richard later regained the upper...

1938

Munich Pact signed

British and French prime ministers Neville Chamberlain and Edouard Daladier sign the Munich Pact with Nazi leader Adolf Hitler. The agreement averted the outbreak of war but gave Czechoslovakia away to German conquest. In the spring of 1938, Hitler began openly to support the demands of German-speakers living in the Sudeten...

1955

James Dean dies

On this day in 1955, movie star James Dean dies at age 24 in a car crash on a California highway. Dean was driving his Porsche 550 Spyder, nicknamed “Little Bastard,” headed to a car race in Salinas, California, with his mechanic Rolf Wuetherich, when they were involved in a...

1962

Riots over desegregation of Ole Miss

In Oxford, Mississippi, James H. Meredith, an African American, is escorted onto the University of Mississippi campus by U.S. Marshals, setting off a deadly riot. Two men were killed before the racial violence was quelled by more than 3,000 federal soldiers. The next day, Meredith successfully enrolled and began to...

Hollywood

2005

Eisner resigns as Disney CEO

On this day in 2005, Michael Eisner resigns as the chief executive officer of the Walt Disney Company. During Eisner’s 21-year tenure with Disney, he helped transform it into an entertainment industry giant whose properties included films, theme parks and a cruise line, television networks and sports teams. Eisner also...

Literary

1868

First volume of Little Women is published

The first volume of Louisa May Alcott’s beloved children’s book Little Women is published on this day. The novel will become Alcott’s first bestseller and a beloved children’s classic. Like the fictional Jo March, Alcott was the second of four daughters. She was born in Pennsylvania but spent most of her...

1928

Elie Wiesel, Holocaust survivor and best-selling author, is born

On this day in 1928, Eliezer “Elie” Wiesel, the human rights activist and Nobel Peace Prize-winning author of more than 50 books, including “Night,” an internationally acclaimed memoir based on his experiences as a prisoner in Nazi concentration camps during World War II, is born in Sighet, Transylvania (present-day Romania). In...

Music

1935

Johnny Mathis is born

Stars like Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin were established enough to survive the rock-and-roll revolution, but the arrival of Elvis Presley, Chuck Berry et al., in the late-1950s did no favors for most of the artists who occupied the top of the pre-rock-and-roll pop charts. Names like Perez Prado, Gogi...

Old West

1889

Wyoming legislators write the first state constitution to grant women the vote

On this day in 1889, the Wyoming state convention approves a constitution that includes a provision granting women the right to vote. Formally admitted into the union the following year, Wyoming thus became the first state in the history of the nation to allow its female citizens to vote. That...

Presidential

1918

President Woodrow Wilson speaks in favor of female suffrage

On this day in 1918, President Woodrow Wilson gives a speech before Congress in support of guaranteeing women the right to vote. Although the House of Representatives had approved a 19th constitutional amendment giving women suffrage, the Senate had yet to vote on the measure. Wilson had actually maintained a somewhat...

Sports

1927

Babe Ruth hits 60th homer of 1927 season

On September 30, 1927, Babe Ruth hits his 60th home run of the 1927 season and with it sets a record that would stand for 34 years. George Herman Ruth was born February 6, 1895, in Baltimore, Maryland. He was the first of eight children, but only he and a sister...

Vietnam War

1964

First large scale antiwar demonstration staged at Berkeley

The first large-scale antiwar demonstration in the United States is staged at the University of California at Berkeley, by students and faculty opposed to the war. Nevertheless, polls showed that a majority of Americans supported President Lyndon Johnson’s policy on the war.

1968

Humphrey announces that he would halt the bombing of North Vietnam

Apparently trying to distance himself from Johnson’s policies, Democratic presidential candidate Hubert Humphrey announces that, if elected, he would halt the bombing of the North if there was any “evidence, direct or indirect, by deed or word, of communist willingness” to restore the Demilitarized Zone between North and South Vietnam. Humphrey...

World War I

1918

Turks abandon Damascus as Allies approach

On the night of September 30, 1918, as Allied forces led by General Edmund Allenby march steadily toward Damascus, Turkish authorities abandon the city. Damascus, located on the Barada River in modern-day Syria, is one of the world’s oldest continuously inhabited cities. Ruled by the Ottoman Empire for centuries, it served...

World War II

1938

Hitler appeased at Munich

On this day in 1938, Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini, French Premier Edouard Daladier, and British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain sign the Munich Pact, which seals the fate of Czechoslovakia, virtually handing it over to Germany in the name of peace. Upon return to Britain, Chamberlain would declare that the meeting...

One thought on “Berlin Airlift Thesis Statement

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *